guide to umbrella and limited companies

Guide to Umbrella & Limited Companies

There are advantages and disadvantages of each. We have put together a simple guide that explains the pros and cons.


In April 2017, there was a fundamental change to the taxation rules for freelancers and contractors operating a limited company (PSC) and working for a public sector body, including the NHS, social care, local authority, police and armed forces, public sector education, BBC and Channel 4, Network Rail.

You need to consider your circumstances and weigh up the options to decide how to operate. You also need to evaluate the risk and what benefits you get so that you don’t lose out.

Sole Trader or Limited Company?

Do you have a question?

We're happy to assist and help answer your questions, please speak to an accountant on Norwich 01603 931177 or request a call back.

What Has Changed?

The responsibility for determining IR35 status has now transferred from the individual operating the PSC to the public sector body they are working for, even if the assignment is through an agency.

Agencies and public sector bodies will deem most contractors as caught by IR35 and operate “deemed payments”, in other words deduct the same amount of tax and NI they would for a normal full-time employee. This, together with the removal of the 5% tax-free allowance and the changes to flat rate VAT means that the take home pay between PSC and Umbrella contracting in the public sector is very similar, although both are probably still better than being employed directly.

If the public sector body decides your contract is caught by IR35, you will be paid “deemed payments”. In other words, they will deduct PAYE and National Insurance from your pay, before paying it to your limited company.

When it comes to contracting, freelancing or locum working, there are two common ways to operate and get paid. There are advantages and disadvantages of each. We have put together a simple guide that explains the pros and cons.

Contracting via an Umbrella Company

Umbrella companies offer flexible workers employment. They take care of all the tax and National Insurance contributions and all the administration. The service is typically very simple and easy to understand. As an employee of the umbrella company you are entitled to statutory employment benefits.

Contracting via a Limited Company

Contracting under a limited company means you are responsible for establishing your company and for submitting all relevant tax and business documentation to HMRC. You will need to establish your limited company and open your business bank account before you can begin operating. The director controls invoicing, the company bank account and decides on how much to pay themselves, which is made up of a combination of salary and dividends.

Your limited company's contract can either be with the end client or the recruitment agency and as long as the contract falls outside of IR35, there are a number of tax expenses you can claim. You will typically take home around 75%-80% of your contract by working through your own limited company.

Umbrella Company - The Advantages

They are easy to set up

Registering with an umbrella company is quick and easy and can often be done online or over the telephone. You will just need to sign a contract and submit a few documents to prove your identity.

There is little administration involved 

To get paid you simply need to submit your timesheet and expenses. Some umbrella companies even offer SMS pay alerts to give you peace of mind.

Centralised PAYE administration 

You don’t need to worry about calculating Income Tax and National Insurance contributions, all this is done for you by the umbrella company.

Statutory employment benefits

Umbrella companies are your employer and will offer you statutory employment benefits, including at least 28 days holiday, national minimum wage, antenatal, maternity and paternity pay.

Extra cover and perks 

Since many umbrella companies look after large numbers of employees, you will probably benefit from comprehensive insurance cover and other perks and discounts to add value to the service.

Low risk, low cost 

Working through an umbrella company is perfect if you want to put flexible working to the test before making a longer-term commitment, or if you are only going to be working as a contractor for a short period. You are not bound to any umbrella business and can easily switch to another umbrella company or set up a limited company.

Umbrella Company - The Disadvantages

You have less control

You do not have as much control over your business activities as you would with a limited company. You also have to rely on the umbrella company processing your invoices and promptly collecting your money.

They will not help you grow

An umbrella company will not support your business plans if you want to develop beyond working as a contractor. Remember that you are an employee of the umbrella company.

Other Income

If you earn income outside your contract you will need to find a way of being paid – be it a new umbrella, limited company or self-employed.


Dependent on your umbrella arrangements you will probably have to claim tax relief on your expenses through a self assessment tax return or a P87.

Not all umbrella companies are equal 

If you use an FCSA-approved Umbrella company you are safe, but it is a fact that there are some less scrupulous operators who claim to be umbrella companies. You must ensure that any deductions are being paid to HMRC and you are not going to face an unexpected tax bill. If your take home pay sounds too good to be true – it probably is. It could be a tax avoidance scheme that may come back to haunt you in the future.

Limited Company - The Advantages

You are in charge

You are in complete control of your business activities. Having your own limited company also means you are regarded as an established, professional business.

Higher pay

Traditionally a limited company may provide you with a higher take-home pay as you can decide on the most tax-efficient way of taking your money (this may not be the case if you are caught by IR35).

You are not restricted 

Since you are running your own business you can undertake activities outside of your normal contracts. If these are not caught by IR35, this part will be outside the deemed payments.

Your company is a separate legal entity to you

Your company is a separate legal entity to you, so your personal finances and assets should be protected in the event of a claim against your company.

You can reclaim more expenses

You can put certain business expenses through your company and take advantage of tax relief on lifestyle benefits, including pensions and life insurance.

Avoid the inconvenience of switching services

If you have been operating as a PSC, switching to an umbrella company will mean changing over to a new system and learning new processes. If you switch agencies you will probably also need to change umbrella provider.

Limited Company - The Disadvantages

Setting it up 

Starting a company requires that you register a company name, address, directors and creating an articles of association document. You will also need to set up a business bank account. You are likely to have problems doing this if you have ever had CCJ’s or been made bankrupt.

Legal obligations 

As the director of a limited company you are responsible for managing your company accounts and ensuring you operate your business in a compliant manner. If you start a personal service company you need to consider IR35. IR35 is a set of rules to identify “disguised employees” i.e. workers who would (in HMRC’s eyes) be classed as an employee, if you removed the fact they have a limited company. Although if you are working in the public sector, the decision is now out of your hands.


There are various official deadlines you must meet. These include filing your accounts, filing your Company Tax Return, paying Corporation Tax and submitting a personal tax return every year.

Financial records 

It is a legal requirement to retain financial records for at least six years from the end of the last company financial year they relate to.

Personal liability  

If you decide to stop trading you are responsible for the cost of closing your business.

Do you have a question? Speak to one of the team on Norwich 01603 931177 or click to Request a Call Back

☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

Excellent Service
I'm very pleased with the input I received from Accountants etc. Would highly recommend.
A. Claxton

☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

Great Price - Very Efficient
Accountants etc. are very efficient and provide us a very good quality of service at a great price.
J. Kemp

☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

Easy to Contact
The team have always been easy to get hold of and happy to help with any queries.
M. Azodoh

☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

Understand my Business
They really understand my business and the team has been very helpful. Great service!
T. Donaldson


Get an instant online quote today & see how much you can save!


We offer low-cost fixed fee pricing which enables you to know exactly how much you're paying. Book a free consultation today!
Call Norwich 01603 931177
Send a Message
Get a Quote


Find the information you need
Our Services
Who we Help



xero receipt bank logo